New Britain, Connecticut · 1857–present
Henry Stanley founded the Stanley Rule & Level Company in New Britain, Connecticut, in 1857, and in 1869 it bought Leonard Bailey's plane patents. Bailey had been building his iron planes in Boston through the 1860s, and the design Stanley took over is still made today. Stanley's own people, Justus Traut among them, kept adding to the line, and by the 1880s Stanley was the biggest toolmaker in America. In 1902 it started casting BAILEY into the plane bodies as a tribute to the inventor. In 1920 the company merged with its cousin's firm, the Stanley Works, and the heart-shaped Sweetheart logo on irons from those years came out of that merger. Collectors date the bench planes with a Type Study of 20 numbered versions running from 1867 into the 1960s.
24 models we cover.
Check the iron's stamp, the lever cap and the body casting. BAILEY is cast into the body from 1902, and from 1925 lever caps carry STANLEY in a notched rectangle. Irons around 1910–1918 have a V-shaped STANLEY NEW BRITAIN CONN. U.S.A. logo, irons from about 1920 to the mid-1930s have the Sweetheart logo (STANLEY over a heart with S.W. inside), and later irons drop the heart. A blue-painted body means 1962 or later. A bright decal on the left side of the tote dates from the 1920s, and reproduction decals have a darker blue-green background than the original aquamarine.

Stanley · Bench plane
No. 11869–1943
$1,350–$2,600 typical ask
3 on eBay

Stanley · Bench plane
No. 21869–1961
$360–$430 typical ask
13 on eBay

Stanley · Bench plane
No. 31869–1984
$45–$70 typical ask
97 on eBay

Stanley · Bench plane
No. 41869–1984
$55–$90 typical ask
159 on eBay

Stanley · Bench plane
No. 4½about 1884–1961
$95–$150 typical ask
42 on eBay
Stanley · Bench plane
No. 51869–1984
$65–$90 typical ask
161 on eBay
Stanley · Bench plane
No. 5½1898–1958
$110–$200 typical ask
26 on eBay
Stanley · Bench plane
No. 61869–1970
$80–$120 typical ask
134 on eBay
Stanley · Bench plane
No. 71869–1970
$130–$210 typical ask
68 on eBay
Stanley · Bench plane
No. 81869–1961
$200–$290 typical ask
34 on eBay
Stanley · Block plane
No. 9½1873–1981
$45–$60 typical ask
73 on eBay

Stanley · Block plane
No. 60½1902–1982
$65–$100 typical ask
17 on eBay
Stanley · Block plane
No. 651898–1969 (knuckle cap about 1917–1960)
$100–$130 typical ask
9 on eBay

Stanley · Specialty plane
No. 451884–1962
$90–$260 typical ask
84 on eBay
Stanley · Specialty plane
No. 551897–1962
$500–$850 typical ask
31 on eBay
Stanley · Specialty plane
No. 711885–1973
$100–$230 typical ask
101 on eBay
Stanley · Specialty plane
No. 781885–1973
$40–$65 typical ask
116 on eBay
Stanley · Specialty plane
No. 921902–1969
$130–$170 typical ask
10 on eBay
Stanley · Spokeshave
No. 511918–1941
$40–$60 typical ask
68 on eBay

Stanley · Spokeshave
No. 1511918–1941
$50–$75 typical ask
32 on eBay
Stanley · Marking tool
No. 651918–1941
$30–$40 typical ask
11 on eBay
Stanley · Marking tool
No. 981918–1941
$35–$45 typical ask
3 on eBay

Stanley · Marking tool
No. 211918–1941
$25–$50 typical ask
23 on eBay

Stanley · Bench chisel
7501930–1969 (Sweetheart logo until about 1935)
$65–$170 typical ask
31 on eBay